December Buyers Find a Deal 46% More Often. That Discount Comes Out of Your Price.

Image for the article.

7 min read · Last updated November 21, 2026

Key takeaways:
  • iSeeCars analyzed over 42 million used-car sales from 2025 through October 2026. December buyers found a priced-below-market “deal” 46.2% more often than the yearly average, followed by January at 44.1% and November at 31.7%.
  • A “deal” in that study means a car listed at least 10% below iSeeCars’ own estimated fair market value. The average used car is now priced at $27,157, so a 10% deal is worth at least $2,716. Every one of those dollars comes out of a December seller’s price, not the buyer’s pocket.
  • February is still a weak month for sellers, 28.8% more deals than average, and March is only neutral at 3.5% above average. The popular “wait for tax-refund season” advice gets you back to even, not to your strongest price.
  • The real low point in deal frequency, meaning the closest buyers get to paying full market value, runs from May through July. June is the single weakest month for buyers, 28.8% fewer deals than average, and the strongest month for sellers.

The best time to sell a car for close to its full value runs from May through July, not the February-to-March tax-refund season most sellers wait for. That’s what iSeeCars’ newest study of 42 million used-car sales actually shows, and it cuts against the advice repeated on most car-selling sites.

The deal you give away to a December buyer is money a May buyer would have paid you without blinking.

In this article

What the new data actually says

iSeeCars published this study on November 10, 2026, built from more than 42 million used-car sales recorded from 2025 through October 2026. It defines a “deal” as a car listed at 10% or more below the site’s own estimated fair market value for that vehicle. It tracks how often buyers find one against a flat daily average of 11.5% of listings.

December came out on top at 46.2% more deals than that average, followed by January at 44.1% and November at 31.7%. On the average used car, now priced at $27,157 according to the same study, a 10% deal is worth at least $2,716. Every one of those dollars comes out of a seller’s pocket, not a dealer’s markup, when the car being sold is a private listing rather than a franchised lot’s inventory.

MonthDeals vs. averageWhat it means if you’re selling
December+46.2%Weakest leverage of the year
January+44.1%Still weak
February+28.8%Improving, still buyer-favored
March+3.5%Close to neutral
April-21.6%Seller’s market begins
May-28.2%Strong seller’s market
June-28.8%Strongest seller’s market of the year
July-25.0%Eases slightly from June’s peak, still well ahead of April
iSeeCars’ percentage of listings selling at least 10% below estimated fair market value, by month, measured against an 11.5% daily average (study published November 10, 2026, covering 2025 through October 2026 sales).

Why tax season isn’t the best time to sell a car

The advice to sell in February or March comes from a real pattern: tax refunds land in most households during that window, and refund cash shows up as car-shopping budget. That part is true. What it skips is that more shoppers with more cash does not automatically mean less bargaining.

February still runs 28.8% above the deal-frequency average in the iSeeCars data. Buyers that month find below-market prices 28.8% more often than a typical day. March drops to just 3.5% above average, close to a normal day, not a seller’s advantage.

The real mirror image of December doesn’t arrive until April, when buyers start struggling to find a discount. That advantage for sellers keeps strengthening through May and peaks in June. July eases slightly from that peak but still beats April by a wide margin, keeping May through July the best time to sell a car by this data.

If you time your listing to tax season because “that’s when buyers have money,” you’re arriving before the discount pressure has actually lifted.

A seller who lists in late February because refund season “is the best time” is still selling into a buyer-friendly month. February runs 28.8% above an average day for buyer deals. Waiting six more weeks, into April, is where the data actually turns in the seller’s favor.

Which cars feel the swing hardest

iSeeCars’ November study covers the whole used-car market, not individual body styles, so treat this section as reasoning from buyer behavior, not a separate dollar figure. A car that’s only useful in good weather, a convertible or a two-seat sports car, has its smallest shopping pool exactly when winter deal-frequency peaks.

Almost nobody test-drives a convertible with the top down in a December parking lot. Sellers of those cars face the fewest interested buyers right when buyers overall have the most leverage.

An all-wheel-drive (AWD) sport-utility vehicle (SUV) or a pickup truck sits on the other side of that same mechanism. Snow and ice are the reason some buyers want one in the first place, so winter shopping demand for those vehicles holds up even while the broader market is buyer-favored.

A smaller price tag in the snowy month, a bigger one in the warm month: the shift in what buyers are willing to pay.
A smaller price tag in the snowy month, a bigger one in the warm month: the shift in what buyers are willing to pay.

That doesn’t cancel out December’s overall weak pricing, but it narrows the gap. A seller with a snow-capable vehicle has more real competition for their listing than a seller with a convertible does, in the same soft month.

What to do if you can’t wait for spring

Selling right now, in a weak month, is still often the right call. A car sitting unsold for five more months costs you in insurance, registration, and depreciation that can exceed the seasonal price gap. If the calendar doesn’t work for you, two things narrow the gap instead of closing it entirely.

First, price at or just under what a comparable car has actually sold for, not the asking prices still-unsold listings are using. Asking-price anchoring is already weaker in a buyer-favored month.

Second, spend on the kind of low-cost cosmetic fix that moves a buyer’s internal condition grade up a tier rather than cutting your price further. A car that photographs and shows like the top of its condition range keeps more of its value even in a month working against you.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and is not financial, legal, or tax advice. Programs, rates, and eligibility rules change frequently. Consult a licensed professional or the relevant government agency for guidance specific to your situation.

Frequently asked questions

Is tax-refund season really the worst advice for selling a car?

Not worst, but weaker than its reputation. February still runs well above the yearly average for buyer deals, and March is only neutral. The window where sellers get genuinely stronger pricing starts closer to April and peaks from May through July.

Does this data mean I should never sell in December?

Not never, but a December seller should expect to negotiate from a weaker position. Buyers that month are 46.2% more likely than average to walk away with a car priced below market value. If you need to sell now, price tighter to recent sold comps and expect less room to move.

Why do all-wheel-drive vehicles and trucks seem to hold up better in winter?

The underlying iSeeCars study doesn’t break results out by body style, but the demand mechanics are straightforward. People shop for snow-capable vehicles specifically because of winter weather, which keeps buyer interest in those vehicles higher than the broader market’s seasonal dip.

Is a private sale still worth more than a dealer trade-in during a weak month like December?

Usually yes, even with winter’s weaker pricing. A trade-in is priced against wholesale, which runs below private-party value in every season. A soft private-sale month typically still beats a trade-in, just by a smaller margin than it would in May or June.

What should I do if I already listed my car in December and it isn’t selling?

Re-check your price against what similar cars have actually sold for in the last two weeks, not what’s still sitting on the market unsold. Consider whether a small cosmetic fix would move your car into a higher condition tier before you cut the price again.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Secret Link